Why do monarchies fall

Spain's monarchy is shaking

A constitutional change is needed

The future of the Spanish monarchy will not be decided solely by how Juan Carlos is dealt with, urges public prosecutor Elisa de la Nuez in El Mundo:

“In any case, the ordinance that secures Juan Carlos I the honorary title of king (after his abdication) must be changed and this honor withdrawn from him. ... But the most important thing is probably to modernize the institution. In addition to the title of king as head of state, the constitution should be supplemented with the necessary guarantees so that the office of head of state, regardless of who holds it, functions efficiently, neutrally and professionally and with the necessary counterweights, sufficient transparency and control and above all the maximum exemplary quality. "

Maintain unity as a republic

Expresso believes that the Spanish monarchy could soon become a republic:

“The pandemic has accelerated history and made scenarios credible that were previously just the mind games of a few. ... The fragmentation of Spain into different nations is a plausible scenario, as is the fragmentation of another compound monarchy, the United Kingdom. Will Spain be united? Or is the maintenance of Spanish unity only possible through a compromise: a regime change and the transition from monarchy to republic? "

A question of character

Because the Spanish royal family lacks an integrating personality at the top, the monarchy could soon be at an end, speculates The Times:

“The latest scandals come at a time when the 1978 constitution is being called into question more than ever because of the Catalan independence movement, and Spanish domestic politics are characterized by deep divisions. ... In such a heated period, a constitutional monarchy can be a source of stability and focus for national unity. But, as the British Queen has so often shown, this stability rests not only on constitutional provisions, but also on the character of the person sitting on the throne. This is a fact that the Spanish monarchy does not take into account - to its own detriment. "

For Spaniards, Europe is more important than ever

The monarchy has had its day as social cement, the Tages-Anzeiger analyzes:

“In the first decades after the dictatorship, Spain lived quite well with this form of government, which held the divided country together to some extent. But the centrifugal forces are getting stronger, meanwhile the monarchy is more of a rift. ... Is Spain ripe for a republic again? In the 1930s, the bitter division of social forces led straight into the civil war. And what would be gained by changing the system? More than this or that representative form of government, the Spaniards are currently saving something else, more contemporary: common European responsibility under the umbrella of the EU. Only they can save the country from poverty caused by the consequences of the corona crisis. The monarchy is more of a staffage. "

Opponents of the monarchy out of government offices

The fact that Spain's socialist prime minister Sánchez rules in coalition with the left-wing party Unidas Podemos, which officially calls for the abolition of the monarchy, is a thorn in the side of ABC:

“Our constitution is a model of coexistence and should not be jeopardized by parties that represent a minority in terms of election results. If Sánchez yesterday Felipe VI. defended, these must not remain empty words. Sánchez has a duty to review his alliance with parties that have proposed the abolition of the monarchy and its symbols. "

Modernization and stability thanks to Juan Carlos

What Juan Carlos I did for Spain for almost forty years is now being forgotten, regrets journalist and writer Juan Luis Cebrián in La Repubblica:

“Even without the crown, post-Frankist Spain would have succeeded in establishing a democratic state system. But the price to be paid would have been higher and the way more difficult. For decades, the presence and attitude of the monarch proved to be decisive for the modernization of the country and for achieving political and social stability. "